Animals Australia Unleashed
Change the World Who Cares? Videos Take Action! The Animals Community Forum Shop Blog Display
1 2 3
Your E-Mail: O Password:
Login Help     |     Join for Free!     |     Hide This

Post a Reply

organ donation

81 - 90 of 191 posts   6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12  


PaulV PaulV NSW Posts: 47
81 6 Apr 2011
xMISSMONSTERx said:
PaulV said:
Chewie said:
Hedwig said:
PaulV said:
self righteous? Not eating animals  is right. No self about it. and just because you did something bad once doesnt excuse people doing it now.
Not everyone is educated or concerned about animal welfare.
Exactly. But that doesn't mean they deserve to die.
You're not addressing the topic, you are not telling me why I should support a person whose lifestyle will result in evil and suffering. Just because they are human? education has nothing to do with it, its the act of food being supplied to them whether they know it or not that came from suffering. If you're fine with the suffering ok, i'm not.
Logically speaking, if you're not okay with suffering, then why are you okay with a human suffering?
its a matter of preventing the most suffering possible. One person eats a lot more animals and causes a lot more suffering if they eat meat . simple equation. prevent the most suffering possible. I dont wish anyone suffering but i have to do my best, and my main concern is that of animals. Its why i'm on unleashed, ANIMALS
ReplyQuote

Nobody Nobody QLD Posts: 593
82 6 Apr 2011
xMISSMONSTERx said:
PaulV said:
Chewie said:
Hedwig said:
PaulV said:
self righteous? Not eating animals  is right. No self about it. and just because you did something bad once doesnt excuse people doing it now.
Not everyone is educated or concerned about animal welfare.
Exactly. But that doesn't mean they deserve to die.
You're not addressing the topic, you are not telling me why I should support a person whose lifestyle will result in evil and suffering. Just because they are human? education has nothing to do with it, its the act of food being supplied to them whether they know it or not that came from suffering. If you're fine with the suffering ok, i'm not.
Logically speaking, if you're not okay with suffering, then why are you okay with a human suffering?
I don't think anybody here is okay with any kind of suffering. The point PaulV is trying to get across is that many animals suffer because of a single meat eater.

EDIT: Paul beat me to it.   tongue
ReplyQuote

PaulV PaulV NSW Posts: 47
83 6 Apr 2011
Dark_Cherry said:
xMISSMONSTERx said:
PaulV said:
Chewie said:
Hedwig said:
PaulV said:
self righteous? Not eating animals  is right. No self about it. and just because you did something bad once doesnt excuse people doing it now.
Not everyone is educated or concerned about animal welfare.
Exactly. But that doesn't mean they deserve to die.
You're not addressing the topic, you are not telling me why I should support a person whose lifestyle will result in evil and suffering. Just because they are human? education has nothing to do with it, its the act of food being supplied to them whether they know it or not that came from suffering. If you're fine with the suffering ok, i'm not.
Logically speaking, if you're not okay with suffering, then why are you okay with a human suffering?
I don't think anybody here is okay with any kind of suffering. The point PaulV is trying to get across is that many animals suffer because of a single meat eater.

EDIT: Paul beat me to it.   tongue
cool
ReplyQuote

Kirrilly Kirrilly VIC Posts: 2092
84 6 Apr 2011
So how far does this go? Vegans and vegetarians can still buy clothes made in sweat shops, hit people with their cars, eat at KFC, join the army, support war and genocide, etc. Would one have to fill out some sort of a questionnaire in order to be considered worthy enough to be saved?
ReplyQuote

Chewie Chewie NSW Posts: 521
85 6 Apr 2011
PaulV said:
xMISSMONSTERx said:
PaulV said:
Chewie said:
Hedwig said:
PaulV said:
self righteous? Not eating animals  is right. No self about it. and just because you did something bad once doesnt excuse people doing it now.
Not everyone is educated or concerned about animal welfare.
Exactly. But that doesn't mean they deserve to die.
You're not addressing the topic, you are not telling me why I should support a person whose lifestyle will result in evil and suffering. Just because they are human? education has nothing to do with it, its the act of food being supplied to them whether they know it or not that came from suffering. If you're fine with the suffering ok, i'm not.
Logically speaking, if you're not okay with suffering, then why are you okay with a human suffering?
its a matter of preventing the most suffering possible. One person eats a lot more animals and causes a lot more suffering if they eat meat . simple equation. prevent the most suffering possible.
One person dying because a vegan didn't want them to have their organ causes significant suffering. Suffering for them, suffering for the life of their unborn child their now widowed wife has in their womb, suffering for their also sick mother or family who relied on them financially, suffering for their community, etc. It's a matter of preventing the most suffering possible. Simple equation. Prevent the most suffering possible.
ReplyQuote

Chewie Chewie NSW Posts: 521
86 6 Apr 2011
PaulD, as I said before, I hope you're not having children. You wouldn't want to cause harm to some animals down the track because you wanted to have sex and reproduce.
ReplyQuote

Chewie Chewie NSW Posts: 521
87 6 Apr 2011
Kirrilly said:
So how far does this go? Vegans and vegetarians can still buy clothes made in sweat shops, hit people with their cars, eat at KFC, join the army, support war and genocide, etc. Would one have to fill out some sort of a questionnaire in order to be considered worthy enough to be saved?
As far as a vegan on their high horse wants it to go... So probably pretty far.
ReplyQuote

Kirrilly Kirrilly VIC Posts: 2092
88 6 Apr 2011
I'd be happy with some sort of last message you could leave to the recipients of your organs, notifying them of your lifestyle and the benefits of being veg/vegan, and asking them to make better choices out of respect for you saving their lives. That ought to be enough to change a few people's minds.

Btw, I'm really cringing at the thought of guests to this forum reading the title of this thread alone, it would be enough to turn me away if I was just visiting for the first time.
ReplyQuote

Nobody Nobody QLD Posts: 593
89 6 Apr 2011
Kirrilly said:
I respect people's right to choose not to donate their organs, but I can't possibly comprehend why they wouldn't.
Well, even before going veg I was unsure of being an organ donor or not because of my beliefs.
I'm not religious - I consider myself a spiritual atheist. I believe in evolution, souls, spirits and reincarnation - and that cutting a body to pieces can cause the soul to be restless or lost.

Maybe it sounds crazy to others, but that's my beliefs.
happy
ReplyQuote

Jacqui T Jacqui T NSW Posts: 796
90 6 Apr 2011
This is a bit off topic but still relevant:

If you saw a man choking on a sausage sandwich, would you go to help resuscitate him or would you just let him choke seeing as he's eating meat?
ReplyQuote

 [ 6 ]  [ 7 ]  [ 8 ]  [ 9 ]  [ 10 ]  [ 11 ]  [ 12 ] 

www.unleashed.org.au