Animals Australia Unleashed
Change the World Who Cares? Videos Take Action! The Animals Community Forum Shop Blog Display
1 2 3
Your E-Mail: O Password:
Login Help     |     Join for Free!     |     Hide This

Post a Reply

plants feel pain...?

1 - 10 of 26 posts   1 | 2 | 3  


karenbaby karenbaby ACT Posts: 489
1 22 Sep 2010
even my mum said trees feel pain.
Is it true all plants feel pain to some extent?
my dad usually thinks something and thinks his right,but he was willing to do a 100$ bett...
i could google it,but does anyone on here actually know? or is it just something silly?
ReplyQuote

ShadowDoubt ShadowDoubt QLD Posts: 753
2 22 Sep 2010
sure plants feel pain. if you pull a carrot out of the ground roughly it can bruise.
but plants don't have central nervous systems.
ReplyQuote

karenbaby karenbaby ACT Posts: 489
3 22 Sep 2010
what woud the  difference be between feeling pain and having a central nervous system?
ReplyQuote

ShadowDoubt ShadowDoubt QLD Posts: 753
4 22 Sep 2010
Louiseeeeee said:
what woud the  difference be between feeling pain and having a central nervous system?
i don't know lol, but if you bruise a carrot it won't go and cry. if you hit an animal, it will become frightened.
ReplyQuote

Brendon Brendon NSW Posts: 1212
5 22 Sep 2010
Plants DO NOT feel pain.
To feel pain you need to have a central nervous system which all plants are lacking.
Also, from an evolutionary perspective a plant feeling pain would be useless as they lack the ability to escape from prey; a key purpose of feeling pain.
Plants do have physiological reactions (such as a carrot bruising) but that's due to the presence of oxygen and a withdrawal from their nutrient dense environment.
They do not feel pain.
ReplyQuote

Kirrilly Kirrilly VIC Posts: 2092
6 22 Sep 2010
They don't feel pain, they can't.
ReplyQuote

karenbaby karenbaby ACT Posts: 489
7 22 Sep 2010
ok thanks happy
ill inform my dad his an idoit haha
ReplyQuote

Cailyn Cailyn QLD Posts: 167
8 22 Sep 2010
They dont feel pain but yeah they can bruise etc
ReplyQuote

ZoolNerd ZoolNerd NSW Posts: 1005
9 22 Sep 2010
BreadmanInAus said:
Plants DO NOT feel pain.
To feel pain you need to have a central nervous system which all plants are lacking.
Also, from an evolutionary perspective a plant feeling pain would be useless as they lack the ability to escape from prey; a key purpose of feeling pain.
Plants do have physiological reactions (such as a carrot bruising) but that's due to the presence of oxygen and a withdrawal from their nutrient dense environment.
They do not feel pain.
That is a perfect answer. I was going to reply and give my own, considering for the past 6 weeks ive been studying plants in Biol in Uni (hate it hate hate it) but yes perfect answer!

Plants need a nervous system. So just to update everyone else, Prokayotes (Bacteria and Archea), Protists (Algae, yeast, plantkon, lots of random stuff) and Fungi and plants ALL DONT FEEL PAIN. Out of all the domains, and kingdoms only Animalia feel pain.Some animals dont feel pain, but they are very very simple organisms. Not your common sheep, lobster, fish, chicken or cow.



EDIT: I just double checked this too:

Pain motivates us to withdraw from potentially damaging situations, protect a damaged body part while it heals, and avoid those situations in the future.  It is initiated by stimulation of nociceptors in the peripheral nervous system, or by damage to or malfunction of the peripheral or central nervous systems.


Its from Wikipedia, but still reliable. Plants do not have nociceptors, peripheral nervous system or central nervous system. BELIEVE ME! I have studied them literally INSIDE AND OUT. (ARGHHHH!!!)  funny
ReplyQuote

meh meh NSW Posts: 2674
10 22 Sep 2010
I've always wondered about sea creatures such as mussels, oysters, clams, etc... do they feel pain? Which sea creatures feel pain and which don't?
ReplyQuote

< Prev
 [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ] 

www.unleashed.org.au